Proficiency testing to assess technical performance for CTC-processing and detection methods in CANCER-ID

Neves RPL, Ammerlaan W, Andree KC, Bender S, Cayrefourcq L, Driemel C, Koch C, Luetke-Eversloh MV, Oulhen M, Rossi E, Alix-Panabières C, Betsou F, Farace F, Riethdorf S, Schlange T, Wikman H, Zamarchi R, Pantel K, Terstappen L, Stoecklein NH, CANCER-ID Consortium.

Clin Chem. 2021. Online ahead of print. February 2021. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33491069

Abstract

Background

Multiple technologies are available for detection of circulating tumor cells (CTCs), but standards to evaluate their technical performance are still lacking. This limits the applicability of CTC analysis in clinic routine. Therefore, in the context of the CANCER-ID consortium, we established a platform to assess technical validity of CTC detection methods in a European multi-center setting using non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) as a model.

Methods

We characterized multiple NSCLC cell lines to define cellular models distinct in their phenotype and molecular characteristics. Standardized tumor-cell-bearing blood samples were prepared at a central laboratory and sent to multiple European laboratories for processing according to standard operating procedures. The data were submitted via an online tool and centrally evaluated. Five CTC-enrichment technologies were tested.

Results

We could identify 2 cytokeratin expressing cell lines with distinct levels of EpCAM expression: NCI-H441 (EpCAMhigh, CKpos) and NCI-H1563 (EpCAMlow, CKpos). Both spiked tumor cell lines were detected by all technologies except for the CellSearch system that failed to enrich EpCAMlow NCI-H1563 cells. Mean recovery rates ranged between 49% and 75% for NCI-H411 and 32% and 76% for NCI-H1563 and significant differences were observed between the tested methods.

Conclusions

This multi-national proficiency testing of CTC-enrichment technologies has importance in the establishment of guidelines for clinically applicable (pre)analytical workflows and the definition of minimal performance qualification requirements prior to clinical validation of technologies. It will remain in operation beyond the funding period of CANCER-ID in the context of the European Liquid Biopsy Society (ELBS).

Publisher